by Don Bora
In a fervor of creativity and adrenaline, we were serendipitously drawn together on a task where fun was one of the top priorities on what would be Eight Bit Studios’ first project. Immediately following the U.S. vice presidential debate between smilin’ Joe Biden and Tina Fey look-alike Sarah Palin, it naturally occurred to two of the bigger nutcases at Eight Bit to have a website dedicated entirely to Joe Biden’s radiant smile.
After dipping my toe in the digital waters where Objective-C frolics in the tide-pools, I had already released my first iPhone application and was enjoying the success that nobody talks about–extremely modest. I should mention that I had been an Objective-C developer back in the early ’90s and I found developing software for the iPhone freakishly invigorating and somewhat addictive. When I caught wind of some of my soon-to-be Eight Bit brethren working on http://joebidensteeth.com the first thought that same into my head was, “You guys need an iPhone app!”
The web site features a glowing portrait of Joe Biden featuring those pearly-whites accompanied by a speech-bubble containing one of several faux satirical quotes. If you refresh the page, a new random quote appears in said speech-bubble. The premise of the iPhone application was simple, the very same glowing portrait of Joe Biden featuring those pearly-whites accompanied by a speech-bubble containing one of several faux satirical quotes. A user can tap on the speech-bubble to refresh the content and receive a new quote. Fun and simple; the perfect ingredients for a snack-sized project.
I had one of the original two nutcases, let’s call him “John” (because that’s his name), move all of the quotes into a separate file so that I could grab it through a URL on app startup. That night I went to work. As the goal was to have this available through the app store by election night, time was tight so I didn’t get fancy and I clamped down the requirements. I sliced my graphics, assembled the XIBs and whipped together the app in under five hours, including the requisite icons for store submission. I put it on my iPhone, showed it off a bit and modestly tested it. Since it was an extrememly simple application, I chose not to adHoc beta test it. I submitted it to the store the following evening.

Dear Mr. Bora,
Thank you for submitting BidensTeeth to the App Store. We’ve reviewed BidensTeeth and determined that we cannot post this version of your iPhone application to the App Store because it contains content that ridicules public figures and is in violation of Section 3.3.12 from the iPhone SDK Agreement which states:
“Applications must not contain any obscene, pornographic, offensive or defamatory content or materials of any kind (text, graphics, images, photographs, etc.), or other content or materials that in Apple’s reasonable judgement may be found objectionable by iPhone or iPod touch users.”
If you believe that you can make the necessary changes so that BidensTeeth does not violate the iPhone SDK Agreement we encourage you to do so and resubmit it for review.
Regards,
iPhone Developer Program
By now, we’ve all seen it. Applications have received this notice for the most innocuous content and functionality. It’s been blogged about, made headlines and been featured in news segments, but for me, on this day, it was new and shocking. A bit of googling revealed the natural next step.
I believe you are in error. Neither the application nor content fits the criteria that you described. The application contains satirical content based on Joe Biden’s fabulous smile. It is not obscene; containing no offensive rhetoric. It is not pornographic; neither words nor images that fit this criterion. It is not offensive; Mr. Biden himself receives good natured commentary with aplomb. It is certainly not defamatory; it does not attack his reputation. It’s satirical.
All of those criteria, however, can be used to describe the content of both online dictionaries and wikipedia.
I ask that you please reconsider this rather harsh pronouncement on a lighthearted and deferential companion application.
We all know how these stories usually end if they’re not blogged about; if they don’t make headlines and they’re not featured in news segments. My entreat went unrecognized by those who have supreme power over the entrance into the captivating repository of realized imagination, that we know as the App Store, featuring over a hundred fart applications.